// Copyright (c) 2013-2016 The btcsuite developers // Copyright (c) 2015-2023 The Decred developers // Use of this source code is governed by an ISC // license that can be found in the LICENSE file. package ecdsa import ( "bytes" "encoding/hex" "errors" "math/rand" "testing" "time" "github.com/decred/dcrd/crypto/blake256" "github.com/decred/dcrd/dcrec/secp256k1/v4" ) // hexToBytes converts the passed hex string into bytes and will panic if there // is an error. This is only provided for the hard-coded constants so errors in // the source code can be detected. It will only (and must only) be called with // hard-coded values. func hexToBytes(s string) []byte { b, err := hex.DecodeString(s) if err != nil { panic("invalid hex in source file: " + s) } return b } // TestSignatureParsing ensures that signatures are properly parsed according // to DER rules. The error paths are tested as well. func TestSignatureParsing(t *testing.T) { tests := []struct { name string sig []byte err error }{{ // signature from Decred blockchain tx // 76634e947f49dfc6228c3e8a09cd3e9e15893439fc06df7df0fc6f08d659856c:0 name: "valid signature 1", sig: hexToBytes("3045022100cd496f2ab4fe124f977ffe3caa09f7576d8a34156" + "b4e55d326b4dffc0399a094022013500a0510b5094bff220c74656879b8ca03" + "69d3da78004004c970790862fc03"), err: nil, }, { // signature from Decred blockchain tx // 76634e947f49dfc6228c3e8a09cd3e9e15893439fc06df7df0fc6f08d659856c:1 name: "valid signature 2", sig: hexToBytes("3044022036334e598e51879d10bf9ce3171666bc2d1bbba6164" + "cf46dd1d882896ba35d5d022056c39af9ea265c1b6d7eab5bc977f06f81e35c" + "dcac16f3ec0fd218e30f2bad2a"), err: nil, }, { name: "empty", sig: nil, err: ErrSigTooShort, }, { name: "too short", sig: hexToBytes("30050201000200"), err: ErrSigTooShort, }, { name: "too long", sig: hexToBytes("3045022100f5353150d31a63f4a0d06d1f5a01ac65f7267a719e" + "49f2a1ac584fd546bef074022030e09575e7a1541aa018876a4003cefe1b061a" + "90556b5140c63e0ef8481352480101"), err: ErrSigTooLong, }, { name: "bad ASN.1 sequence id", sig: hexToBytes("3145022100f5353150d31a63f4a0d06d1f5a01ac65f7267a719e" + "49f2a1ac584fd546bef074022030e09575e7a1541aa018876a4003cefe1b061a" + "90556b5140c63e0ef848135248"), err: ErrSigInvalidSeqID, }, { name: "mismatched data length (short one byte)", sig: hexToBytes("3044022100f5353150d31a63f4a0d06d1f5a01ac65f7267a719e" + "49f2a1ac584fd546bef074022030e09575e7a1541aa018876a4003cefe1b061a" + "90556b5140c63e0ef848135248"), err: ErrSigInvalidDataLen, }, { name: "mismatched data length (long one byte)", sig: hexToBytes("3046022100f5353150d31a63f4a0d06d1f5a01ac65f7267a719e" + "49f2a1ac584fd546bef074022030e09575e7a1541aa018876a4003cefe1b061a" + "90556b5140c63e0ef848135248"), err: ErrSigInvalidDataLen, }, { name: "bad R ASN.1 int marker", sig: hexToBytes("304403204e45e16932b8af514961a1d3a1a25fdf3f4f7732e9d6" + "24c6c61548ab5fb8cd410220181522ec8eca07de4860a4acdd12909d831cc56c" + "bbac4622082221a8768d1d09"), err: ErrSigInvalidRIntID, }, { name: "zero R length", sig: hexToBytes("30240200022030e09575e7a1541aa018876a4003cefe1b061a90" + "556b5140c63e0ef848135248"), err: ErrSigZeroRLen, }, { name: "negative R (too little padding)", sig: hexToBytes("30440220b2ec8d34d473c3aa2ab5eb7cc4a0783977e5db8c8daf" + "777e0b6d7bfa6b6623f302207df6f09af2c40460da2c2c5778f636d3b2e27e20" + "d10d90f5a5afb45231454700"), err: ErrSigNegativeR, }, { name: "too much R padding", sig: hexToBytes("304402200077f6e93de5ed43cf1dfddaa79fca4b766e1a8fc879" + "b0333d377f62538d7eb5022054fed940d227ed06d6ef08f320976503848ed1f5" + "2d0dd6d17f80c9c160b01d86"), err: ErrSigTooMuchRPadding, }, { name: "bad S ASN.1 int marker", sig: hexToBytes("3045022100f5353150d31a63f4a0d06d1f5a01ac65f7267a719e" + "49f2a1ac584fd546bef074032030e09575e7a1541aa018876a4003cefe1b061a" + "90556b5140c63e0ef848135248"), err: ErrSigInvalidSIntID, }, { name: "missing S ASN.1 int marker", sig: hexToBytes("3023022100f5353150d31a63f4a0d06d1f5a01ac65f7267a719e" + "49f2a1ac584fd546bef074"), err: ErrSigMissingSTypeID, }, { name: "S length missing", sig: hexToBytes("3024022100f5353150d31a63f4a0d06d1f5a01ac65f7267a719e" + "49f2a1ac584fd546bef07402"), err: ErrSigMissingSLen, }, { name: "invalid S length (short one byte)", sig: hexToBytes("3045022100f5353150d31a63f4a0d06d1f5a01ac65f7267a719e" + "49f2a1ac584fd546bef074021f30e09575e7a1541aa018876a4003cefe1b061a" + "90556b5140c63e0ef848135248"), err: ErrSigInvalidSLen, }, { name: "invalid S length (long one byte)", sig: hexToBytes("3045022100f5353150d31a63f4a0d06d1f5a01ac65f7267a719e" + "49f2a1ac584fd546bef074022130e09575e7a1541aa018876a4003cefe1b061a" + "90556b5140c63e0ef848135248"), err: ErrSigInvalidSLen, }, { name: "zero S length", sig: hexToBytes("3025022100f5353150d31a63f4a0d06d1f5a01ac65f7267a719e" + "49f2a1ac584fd546bef0740200"), err: ErrSigZeroSLen, }, { name: "negative S (too little padding)", sig: hexToBytes("304402204fc10344934662ca0a93a84d14d650d8a21cf2ab91f6" + "08e8783d2999c955443202208441aacd6b17038ff3f6700b042934f9a6fea0ce" + "c2051b51dc709e52a5bb7d61"), err: ErrSigNegativeS, }, { name: "too much S padding", sig: hexToBytes("304402206ad2fdaf8caba0f2cb2484e61b81ced77474b4c2aa06" + "9c852df1351b3314fe20022000695ad175b09a4a41cd9433f6b2e8e83253d6a7" + "402096ba313a7be1f086dde5"), err: ErrSigTooMuchSPadding, }, { name: "R == 0", sig: hexToBytes("30250201000220181522ec8eca07de4860a4acdd12909d831cc5" + "6cbbac4622082221a8768d1d09"), err: ErrSigRIsZero, }, { name: "R == N", sig: hexToBytes("3045022100fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffebaaedce6af" + "48a03bbfd25e8cd03641410220181522ec8eca07de4860a4acdd12909d831cc5" + "6cbbac4622082221a8768d1d09"), err: ErrSigRTooBig, }, { name: "R > N (>32 bytes)", sig: hexToBytes("3045022101cd496f2ab4fe124f977ffe3caa09f756283910fc1a" + "96f60ee6873e88d3cfe1d50220181522ec8eca07de4860a4acdd12909d831cc5" + "6cbbac4622082221a8768d1d09"), err: ErrSigRTooBig, }, { name: "R > N", sig: hexToBytes("3045022100fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffebaaedce6af" + "48a03bbfd25e8cd03641420220181522ec8eca07de4860a4acdd12909d831cc5" + "6cbbac4622082221a8768d1d09"), err: ErrSigRTooBig, }, { name: "S == 0", sig: hexToBytes("302502204e45e16932b8af514961a1d3a1a25fdf3f4f7732e9d6" + "24c6c61548ab5fb8cd41020100"), err: ErrSigSIsZero, }, { name: "S == N", sig: hexToBytes("304502204e45e16932b8af514961a1d3a1a25fdf3f4f7732e9d6" + "24c6c61548ab5fb8cd41022100fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffebaaedc" + "e6af48a03bbfd25e8cd0364141"), err: ErrSigSTooBig, }, { name: "S > N (>32 bytes)", sig: hexToBytes("304502204e45e16932b8af514961a1d3a1a25fdf3f4f7732e9d6" + "24c6c61548ab5fb8cd4102210113500a0510b5094bff220c74656879b784b246" + "ba89c0a07bc49bcf05d8993d44"), err: ErrSigSTooBig, }, { name: "S > N", sig: hexToBytes("304502204e45e16932b8af514961a1d3a1a25fdf3f4f7732e9d6" + "24c6c61548ab5fb8cd41022100fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffebaaedc" + "e6af48a03bbfd25e8cd0364142"), err: ErrSigSTooBig, }} for _, test := range tests { _, err := ParseDERSignature(test.sig) if !errors.Is(err, test.err) { t.Errorf("%s mismatched err -- got %v, want %v", test.name, err, test.err) continue } } } // TestSignatureSerialize ensures that serializing signatures works as expected. func TestSignatureSerialize(t *testing.T) { tests := []struct { name string ecsig *Signature expected []byte }{{ // signature from bitcoin blockchain tx // 0437cd7f8525ceed2324359c2d0ba26006d92d85 "valid 1 - r and s most significant bits are zero", &Signature{ r: *hexToModNScalar("4e45e16932b8af514961a1d3a1a25fdf3f4f7732e9d624c6c61548ab5fb8cd41"), s: *hexToModNScalar("181522ec8eca07de4860a4acdd12909d831cc56cbbac4622082221a8768d1d09"), }, hexToBytes("304402204e45e16932b8af514961a1d3a1a25fdf3f4f7732e9d62" + "4c6c61548ab5fb8cd410220181522ec8eca07de4860a4acdd12909d831cc" + "56cbbac4622082221a8768d1d09"), }, { // signature from bitcoin blockchain tx // cb00f8a0573b18faa8c4f467b049f5d202bf1101d9ef2633bc611be70376a4b4 "valid 2 - r most significant bit is one", &Signature{ r: *hexToModNScalar("82235e21a2300022738dabb8e1bbd9d19cfb1e7ab8c30a23b0afbb8d178abcf3"), s: *hexToModNScalar("24bf68e256c534ddfaf966bf908deb944305596f7bdcc38d69acad7f9c868724"), }, hexToBytes("304502210082235e21a2300022738dabb8e1bbd9d19cfb1e7ab8c" + "30a23b0afbb8d178abcf3022024bf68e256c534ddfaf966bf908deb94430" + "5596f7bdcc38d69acad7f9c868724"), }, { // signature from bitcoin blockchain tx // fda204502a3345e08afd6af27377c052e77f1fefeaeb31bdd45f1e1237ca5470 // // Note that signatures with an S component that is > half the group // order are neither allowed nor produced in Decred, so this has been // modified to expect the equally valid low S signature variant. "valid 3 - s most significant bit is one", &Signature{ r: *hexToModNScalar("1cadddc2838598fee7dc35a12b340c6bde8b389f7bfd19a1252a17c4b5ed2d71"), s: *hexToModNScalar("c1a251bbecb14b058a8bd77f65de87e51c47e95904f4c0e9d52eddc21c1415ac"), }, hexToBytes("304402201cadddc2838598fee7dc35a12b340c6bde8b389f7bfd1" + "9a1252a17c4b5ed2d7102203e5dae44134eb4fa757428809a2178199e66f" + "38daa53df51eaa380cab4222b95"), }, { "zero signature", &Signature{ r: *new(secp256k1.ModNScalar).SetInt(0), s: *new(secp256k1.ModNScalar).SetInt(0), }, hexToBytes("3006020100020100"), }} for i, test := range tests { result := test.ecsig.Serialize() if !bytes.Equal(result, test.expected) { t.Errorf("Serialize #%d (%s) unexpected result:\n"+ "got: %x\nwant: %x", i, test.name, result, test.expected) } } } // signTest describes tests for producing and verifying ECDSA signatures for a // selected set of private keys, messages, and nonces that have been verified // independently with the Sage computer algebra system. It is defined // separately since it is intended for use in both normal and compact signature // tests. type signTest struct { name string // test description key string // hex encoded private key msg string // hex encoded message to sign before hashing hash string // hex encoded hash of the message to sign nonce string // hex encoded nonce to use in the signature calculation rfc6979 bool // whether or not the nonce is an RFC6979 nonce wantSigR string // hex encoded expected signature R wantSigS string // hex encoded expected signature S wantCode byte // expected public key recovery code } // signTests returns several tests for ECDSA signatures that use a selected set // of private keys, messages, and nonces that have been verified independently // with the Sage computer algebra system. It is defined here versus inside a // specific test function scope so it can be shared for both normal and compact // signature tests. func signTests(t *testing.T) []signTest { t.Helper() tests := []signTest{{ name: "key 0x1, blake256(0x01020304), rfc6979 nonce", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001", msg: "01020304", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", nonce: "4154324ecd4158938f1df8b5b659aeb639c7fbc36005934096e514af7d64bcc2", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "c6c4137b0e5fbfc88ae3f293d7e80c8566c43ae20340075d44f75b009c943d09", wantSigS: "00ba213513572e35943d5acdd17215561b03f11663192a7252196cc8b2a99560", wantCode: 0, }, { name: "key 0x1, blake256(0x01020304), random nonce", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001", msg: "01020304", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", nonce: "a6df66500afeb7711d4c8e2220960855d940a5ed57260d2c98fbf6066cca283e", rfc6979: false, wantSigR: "b073759a96a835b09b79e7b93c37fdbe48fb82b000c4a0e1404ba5d1fbc15d0a", wantSigS: "7e34928a3e3832ec21e7711644d9388f7deb6340ead661d7056b0665974b87f3", wantCode: pubKeyRecoveryCodeOddnessBit, }, { name: "key 0x2, blake256(0x01020304), rfc6979 nonce", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000002", msg: "01020304", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", nonce: "55f96f24cf7531f527edfe3b9222eca12d575367c32a7f593a828dc3651acf49", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "e6f137b52377250760cc702e19b7aee3c63b0e7d95a91939b14ab3b5c4771e59", wantSigS: "44b9bc4620afa158b7efdfea5234ff2d5f2f78b42886f02cf581827ee55318ea", wantCode: pubKeyRecoveryCodeOddnessBit, }, { name: "key 0x2, blake256(0x01020304), random nonce", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000002", msg: "01020304", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", nonce: "679a6d36e7fe6c02d7668af86d78186e8f9ccc04371ac1c8c37939d1f5cae07a", rfc6979: false, wantSigR: "4a090d82f48ca12d9e7aa24b5dcc187ee0db2920496f671d63e86036aaa7997e", wantSigS: "261ffe8ba45007fc5fbbba6b4c6ed41beafb48b09fa8af1d6a3fbc6ccefbad", wantCode: 0, }, { name: "key 0x1, blake256(0x0102030405), rfc6979 nonce", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001", msg: "0102030405", hash: "dc063eba3c8d52a159e725c1a161506f6cb6b53478ad5ef3f08d534efa871d9f", nonce: "aa87a543c68f2568bb107c9946afa5233bf94fb6a7a063544505282621021629", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "dda8308cdbda2edf51ccf598b42b42b19597e102eb2ed4a04a16dd57084d3b40", wantSigS: "0b6d67bab4929624e28f690407a15efc551354544fdc179970ff401eec2e5dc9", wantCode: pubKeyRecoveryCodeOddnessBit, }, { name: "key 0x1, blake256(0x0102030405), random nonce", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001", msg: "0102030405", hash: "dc063eba3c8d52a159e725c1a161506f6cb6b53478ad5ef3f08d534efa871d9f", nonce: "65f880c892fdb6e7f74f76b18c7c942cfd037ef9cf97c39c36e08bbc36b41616", rfc6979: false, wantSigR: "72e5666f4e9d1099447b825cf737ee32112f17a67e2ca7017ae098da31dfbb8b", wantSigS: "1a7326da661a62f66358dcf53300afdc8e8407939dae1192b5b0899b0254311b", wantCode: pubKeyRecoveryCodeOddnessBit, }, { name: "key 0x2, blake256(0x0102030405), rfc6979 nonce", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000002", msg: "0102030405", hash: "dc063eba3c8d52a159e725c1a161506f6cb6b53478ad5ef3f08d534efa871d9f", nonce: "a13d652abd54b6e862548e5d12716df14dc192d93f3fa13536fdf4e56c54f233", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "122663fd29e41a132d3c8329cf05d61ebcca9351074cc277dcd868faba58d87d", wantSigS: "353a44f2d949c04981e4e4d9c1f93a9e0644e63a5eaa188288c5ad68fd288d40", wantCode: 0, }, { name: "key 0x2, blake256(0x0102030405), random nonce", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000002", msg: "0102030405", hash: "dc063eba3c8d52a159e725c1a161506f6cb6b53478ad5ef3f08d534efa871d9f", nonce: "026ece4cfb704733dd5eef7898e44c33bd5a0d749eb043f48705e40fa9e9afa0", rfc6979: false, wantSigR: "3c4c5a2f217ea758113fd4e89eb756314dfad101a300f48e5bd764d3b6e0f8bf", wantSigS: "6513e82442f133cb892514926ed9158328ead488ff1b027a31827603a65009df", wantCode: pubKeyRecoveryCodeOddnessBit, }, { name: "random key 1, blake256(0x01), rfc6979 nonce", key: "a1becef2069444a9dc6331c3247e113c3ee142edda683db8643f9cb0af7cbe33", msg: "01", hash: "4a6c419a1e25c85327115c4ace586decddfe2990ed8f3d4d801871158338501d", nonce: "edb3a01063a0c6ccfc0d77295077cbd322cf364bfa64b7eeea3b20305135d444", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "ef392791d87afca8256c4c9c68d981248ee34a09069f50fa8dfc19ae34cd92ce", wantSigS: "0a2b9cb69fd794f7f204c272293b8585a294916a21a11fd94ec04acae2dc6d21", wantCode: 0, }, { name: "random key 2, blake256(0x02), rfc6979 nonce", key: "59930b76d4b15767ec0e8c8e5812aa2e57db30c6af7963e2a6295ba02af5416b", msg: "02", hash: "49af37ab5270015fe25276ea5a3bb159d852943df23919522a202205fb7d175c", nonce: "af2a59085976494567ef0fc2ecede587b2d1d8e9898cc46e72d7f3e33156e057", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "886c9cccb356b3e1deafef2c276a4f8717ab73c1244c3f673cfbff5897de0e06", wantSigS: "609394185495f978ae84b69be90c69947e5dd8dcb4726da604fcbd139d81fc55", wantCode: 0, }, { name: "random key 3, blake256(0x03), rfc6979 nonce", key: "c5b205c36bb7497d242e96ec19a2a4f086d8daa919135cf490d2b7c0230f0e91", msg: "03", hash: "b706d561742ad3671703c247eb927ee8a386369c79644131cdeb2c5c26bf6c5d", nonce: "82d82b696a386d6d7a111c4cb943bfd39de8e5f6195e7eed9d3edb40fe1419fa", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "6589d5950cec1fe2e7e20593b5ffa3556de20c176720a1796aa77a0cec1ec5a7", wantSigS: "2a26deba3241de852e786f5b4e2b98d3efb958d91fe9773b331dbcca9e8be800", wantCode: 0, }, { name: "random key 4, blake256(0x04), rfc6979 nonce", key: "65b46d4eb001c649a86309286aaf94b18386effe62c2e1586d9b1898ccf0099b", msg: "04", hash: "4c6eb9e38415034f4c93d3304d10bef38bf0ad420eefd0f72f940f11c5857786", nonce: "7afd696a9e770961d2b2eaec77ab7c22c734886fa57bc4a50a9f1946168cd06f", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "81db1d6dca08819ad936d3284a359091e57c036648d477b96af9d8326965a7d1", wantSigS: "1bdf719c4be69351ba7617a187ac246912101aea4b5a7d6dfc234478622b43c6", wantCode: pubKeyRecoveryCodeOddnessBit, }, { name: "random key 5, blake256(0x05), rfc6979 nonce", key: "915cb9ba4675de06a182088b182abcf79fa8ac989328212c6b866fa3ec2338f9", msg: "05", hash: "bdd15db13448905791a70b68137445e607cca06cc71c7a58b9b2e84a06c54d08", nonce: "2a6ae70ea5cf1b932331901d640ece54551f5f33bf9484d5f95c676b5612b527", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "47fd51aecbc743477cb59aa29d18d11d75fb206ae1cdd044216e4f294e33d5b6", wantSigS: "3d50edc03066584d50b8d19d681865a23960b37502ede5bf452bdca56744334a", wantCode: pubKeyRecoveryCodeOddnessBit, }, { name: "random key 6, blake256(0x06), rfc6979 nonce", key: "93e9d81d818f08ba1f850c6dfb82256b035b42f7d43c1fe090804fb009aca441", msg: "06", hash: "19b7506ad9c189a9f8b063d2aee15953d335f5c88480f8515d7d848e7771c4ae", nonce: "0b847a0ae0cbe84dfca66621f04f04b0f2ec190dce10d43ba8c3915c0fcd90ed", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "c99800bc7ac7ea11afe5d7a264f4c26edd63ae9c7ecd6d0d19992980bcda1d34", wantSigS: "2844d4c9020ddf9e96b86c1a04788e0f371bd562291fd17ee017db46259d04fb", wantCode: pubKeyRecoveryCodeOddnessBit, }, { name: "random key 7, blake256(0x07), rfc6979 nonce", key: "c249bbd5f533672b7dcd514eb1256854783531c2b85fe60bf4ce6ea1f26afc2b", msg: "07", hash: "53d661e71e47a0a7e416591200175122d83f8af31be6a70af7417ad6f54d0038", nonce: "0f8e20694fe766d7b79e5ac141e3542f2f3c3d2cc6d0f60e0ec263a46dbe6d49", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "7a57a5222fb7d615eaa0041193f682262cebfa9b448f9c519d3644d0a3348521", wantSigS: "574923b7b5aec66b62f1589002db29342c9f5ed56d5e80f5361c0307ff1561fa", wantCode: 0, }, { name: "random key 8, blake256(0x08), rfc6979 nonce", key: "ec0be92fcec66cf1f97b5c39f83dfd4ddcad0dad468d3685b5eec556c6290bcc", msg: "08", hash: "9bff7982eab6f7883322edf7bdc86a23c87ca1c07906fbb1584f57b197dc6253", nonce: "ab7df49257d18f5f1b730cc7448f46bd82eb43e6e220f521fa7d23802310e24d", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "64f90b09c8b1763a3eeefd156e5d312f80a98c24017811c0163b1c0b01323668", wantSigS: "7d7bf4ff295ecfc9578eadc8378b0eea0c0362ad083b0fd1c9b3c06f4537f6ff", wantCode: pubKeyRecoveryCodeOddnessBit, }, { name: "random key 9, blake256(0x09), rfc6979 nonce", key: "6847b071a7cba6a85099b26a9c3e57a964e4990620e1e1c346fecc4472c4d834", msg: "09", hash: "4c2231813064f8500edae05b40195416bd543fd3e76c16d6efb10c816d92e8b6", nonce: "48ea6c907e1cda596048d812439ccf416eece9a7de400c8a0e40bd48eb7e613a", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "81fc600775d3cdcaa14f8629537299b8226a0c8bfce9320ce64a8d14e3f95bae", wantSigS: "3607997d36b48bce957ae9b3d450e0969f6269554312a82bf9499efc8280ea6d", wantCode: 0, }, { name: "random key 10, blake256(0x0a), rfc6979 nonce", key: "b7548540f52fe20c161a0d623097f827608c56023f50442cc00cc50ad674f6b5", msg: "0a", hash: "e81db4f0d76e02805155441f50c861a8f86374f3ae34c7a3ff4111d3a634ecb1", nonce: "95c07e315cd5457e84270ca01019563c8eeaffb18ab4f23e88a44a0ff01c5f6f", rfc6979: true, wantSigR: "0d4cbf2da84f7448b083fce9b9c4e1834b5e2e98defcec7ec87e87c739f5fe78", wantSigS: "0997db60683e12b4494702347fc7ae7f599e5a95c629c146e0fc615a1a2acac5", wantCode: pubKeyRecoveryCodeOddnessBit, }} // Ensure the test data is sane by comparing the provided hashed message and // nonce, in the case RFC6979 was used, to their calculated values. These // values could just be calculated instead of specified in the test data, // but it's nice to have all of the calculated values available in the test // data for cross implementation testing and verification. for _, test := range tests { msg := hexToBytes(test.msg) hash := hexToBytes(test.hash) calcHash := blake256.Sum256(msg) if !bytes.Equal(calcHash[:], hash) { t.Errorf("%s: mismatched test hash -- expected: %x, given: %x", test.name, calcHash[:], hash) continue } if test.rfc6979 { privKeyBytes := hexToBytes(test.key) nonceBytes := hexToBytes(test.nonce) calcNonce := secp256k1.NonceRFC6979(privKeyBytes, hash, nil, nil, 0) calcNonceBytes := calcNonce.Bytes() if !bytes.Equal(calcNonceBytes[:], nonceBytes) { t.Errorf("%s: mismatched test nonce -- expected: %x, given: %x", test.name, calcNonceBytes, nonceBytes) continue } } } return tests } // TestSignAndVerify ensures the ECDSA signing function produces the expected // signatures for a selected set of private keys, messages, and nonces that have // been verified independently with the Sage computer algebra system. It also // ensures verifying the signature works as expected. func TestSignAndVerify(t *testing.T) { t.Parallel() tests := signTests(t) for _, test := range tests { privKey := secp256k1.NewPrivateKey(hexToModNScalar(test.key)) hash := hexToBytes(test.hash) nonce := hexToModNScalar(test.nonce) wantSigR := hexToModNScalar(test.wantSigR) wantSigS := hexToModNScalar(test.wantSigS) wantSig := NewSignature(wantSigR, wantSigS).Serialize() // Sign the hash of the message with the given private key and nonce. gotSig, recoveryCode, success := sign(&privKey.Key, nonce, hash) if !success { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected error when signing", test.name) continue } // Ensure the generated signature is the expected value. gotSigBytes := gotSig.Serialize() if !bytes.Equal(gotSigBytes, wantSig) { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected signature -- got %x, want %x", test.name, gotSigBytes, wantSig) continue } // Ensure the generated public key recovery code is the expected value. if recoveryCode != test.wantCode { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected recovery code -- got %x, want %x", test.name, recoveryCode, test.wantCode) continue } // Ensure the R method returns the expected value. gotSigR := gotSig.R() if !gotSigR.Equals(wantSigR) { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected R component -- got %064x, want %064x", test.name, gotSigR.Bytes(), wantSigR.Bytes()) } // Ensure the S method returns the expected value. gotSigS := gotSig.S() if !gotSigS.Equals(wantSigS) { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected S component -- got %064x, want %064x", test.name, gotSigS.Bytes(), wantSigS.Bytes()) } // Ensure the produced signature verifies. pubKey := privKey.PubKey() if !gotSig.Verify(hash, pubKey) { t.Errorf("%s: signature failed to verify", test.name) continue } // Ensure the signature generated by the exported method is the expected // value as well in the case RFC6979 was used. if test.rfc6979 { gotSig = Sign(privKey, hash) gotSigBytes := gotSig.Serialize() if !bytes.Equal(gotSigBytes, wantSig) { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected signature -- got %x, want %x", test.name, gotSigBytes, wantSig) continue } } } } // TestSignAndVerifyRandom ensures ECDSA signing and verification work as // expected for randomly-generated private keys and messages. It also ensures // invalid signatures are not improperly verified by mutating the valid // signature and changing the message the signature covers. func TestSignAndVerifyRandom(t *testing.T) { t.Parallel() // Use a unique random seed each test instance and log it if the tests fail. seed := time.Now().Unix() rng := rand.New(rand.NewSource(seed)) defer func(t *testing.T, seed int64) { if t.Failed() { t.Logf("random seed: %d", seed) } }(t, seed) for i := 0; i < 100; i++ { // Generate a random private key. var buf [32]byte if _, err := rng.Read(buf[:]); err != nil { t.Fatalf("failed to read random private key: %v", err) } var privKeyScalar secp256k1.ModNScalar privKeyScalar.SetBytes(&buf) privKey := secp256k1.NewPrivateKey(&privKeyScalar) // Generate a random hash to sign. var hash [32]byte if _, err := rng.Read(hash[:]); err != nil { t.Fatalf("failed to read random hash: %v", err) } // Sign the hash with the private key and then ensure the produced // signature is valid for the hash and public key associated with the // private key. sig := Sign(privKey, hash[:]) pubKey := privKey.PubKey() if !sig.Verify(hash[:], pubKey) { t.Fatalf("failed to verify signature\nsig: %x\nhash: %x\n"+ "private key: %x\npublic key: %x", sig.Serialize(), hash, privKey.Serialize(), pubKey.SerializeCompressed()) } // Change a random bit in the signature and ensure the bad signature // fails to verify the original message. badSig := *sig randByte := rng.Intn(32) randBit := rng.Intn(7) if randComponent := rng.Intn(2); randComponent == 0 { badSigBytes := badSig.r.Bytes() badSigBytes[randByte] ^= 1 << randBit badSig.r.SetBytes(&badSigBytes) } else { badSigBytes := badSig.s.Bytes() badSigBytes[randByte] ^= 1 << randBit badSig.s.SetBytes(&badSigBytes) } if badSig.Verify(hash[:], pubKey) { t.Fatalf("verified bad signature\nsig: %x\nhash: %x\n"+ "private key: %x\npublic key: %x", badSig.Serialize(), hash, privKey.Serialize(), pubKey.SerializeCompressed()) } // Change a random bit in the hash that was originally signed and ensure // the original good signature fails to verify the new bad message. badHash := make([]byte, len(hash)) copy(badHash, hash[:]) randByte = rng.Intn(len(badHash)) randBit = rng.Intn(7) badHash[randByte] ^= 1 << randBit if sig.Verify(badHash, pubKey) { t.Fatalf("verified signature for bad hash\nsig: %x\nhash: %x\n"+ "pubkey: %x", sig.Serialize(), badHash, pubKey.SerializeCompressed()) } } } // TestSignFailures ensures the internal ECDSA signing function returns an // unsuccessful result when particular combinations of values are unable to // produce a valid signature. func TestSignFailures(t *testing.T) { t.Parallel() tests := []struct { name string // test description key string // hex encoded private key hash string // hex encoded hash of the message to sign nonce string // hex encoded nonce to use in the signature calculation }{{ name: "zero R is invalid (forced by using zero nonce)", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", nonce: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000", }, { name: "zero S is invalid (forced by key/hash/nonce choice)", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001", hash: "393bec84f1a04037751c0d6c2817f37953eaa204ac0898de7adb038c33a20438", nonce: "4154324ecd4158938f1df8b5b659aeb639c7fbc36005934096e514af7d64bcc2", }} for _, test := range tests { privKey := hexToModNScalar(test.key) hash := hexToBytes(test.hash) nonce := hexToModNScalar(test.nonce) // Ensure the signing is NOT successful. sig, _, success := sign(privKey, nonce, hash) if success { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected success -- got sig %x", test.name, sig.Serialize()) continue } } } // TestVerifyFailures ensures the ECDSA verification function returns an // unsuccessful result for edge conditions. func TestVerifyFailures(t *testing.T) { t.Parallel() tests := []struct { name string // test description key string // hex encoded private key hash string // hex encoded hash of the message to sign r, s string // hex encoded r and s components of signature to verify }{{ name: "signature R is 0", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", r: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000", s: "00ba213513572e35943d5acdd17215561b03f11663192a7252196cc8b2a99560", }, { name: "signature S is 0", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", r: "c6c4137b0e5fbfc88ae3f293d7e80c8566c43ae20340075d44f75b009c943d09", s: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000", }, { name: "u1G + u2Q is the point at infinity", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", r: "3cfe45621a29fac355260a14b9adc0fe43ac2f13e918fc9ddfa117e964b61a8a", s: "00ba213513572e35943d5acdd17215561b03f11663192a7252196cc8b2a99560", }, { name: "signature R < P-N, but invalid", key: "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", r: "000000000000000000000000000000014551231950b75fc4402da1722fc9baed", s: "00ba213513572e35943d5acdd17215561b03f11663192a7252196cc8b2a99560", }} for _, test := range tests { privKey := hexToModNScalar(test.key) hash := hexToBytes(test.hash) r := hexToModNScalar(test.r) s := hexToModNScalar(test.s) sig := NewSignature(r, s) // Ensure the verification is NOT successful. pubKey := secp256k1.NewPrivateKey(privKey).PubKey() if sig.Verify(hash, pubKey) { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected success for invalid signature: %x", test.name, sig.Serialize()) continue } } } // TestSignatureIsEqual ensures that equality testing between two signatures // works as expected. func TestSignatureIsEqual(t *testing.T) { sig1 := &Signature{ r: *hexToModNScalar("82235e21a2300022738dabb8e1bbd9d19cfb1e7ab8c30a23b0afbb8d178abcf3"), s: *hexToModNScalar("24bf68e256c534ddfaf966bf908deb944305596f7bdcc38d69acad7f9c868724"), } sig1Copy := &Signature{ r: *hexToModNScalar("82235e21a2300022738dabb8e1bbd9d19cfb1e7ab8c30a23b0afbb8d178abcf3"), s: *hexToModNScalar("24bf68e256c534ddfaf966bf908deb944305596f7bdcc38d69acad7f9c868724"), } sig2 := &Signature{ r: *hexToModNScalar("4e45e16932b8af514961a1d3a1a25fdf3f4f7732e9d624c6c61548ab5fb8cd41"), s: *hexToModNScalar("181522ec8eca07de4860a4acdd12909d831cc56cbbac4622082221a8768d1d09"), } if !sig1.IsEqual(sig1) { t.Fatalf("bad self signature equality check: %v == %v", sig1, sig1Copy) } if !sig1.IsEqual(sig1Copy) { t.Fatalf("bad signature equality check: %v == %v", sig1, sig1Copy) } if sig1.IsEqual(sig2) { t.Fatalf("bad signature equality check: %v != %v", sig1, sig2) } } // TestSignAndRecoverCompact ensures compact (recoverable public key) ECDSA // signing and public key recovery works as expected for a selected set of // private keys, messages, and nonces that have been verified independently with // the Sage computer algebra system. func TestSignAndRecoverCompact(t *testing.T) { t.Parallel() tests := signTests(t) for _, test := range tests { // Skip tests using nonces that are not RFC6979. if !test.rfc6979 { continue } // Parse test data. privKey := secp256k1.NewPrivateKey(hexToModNScalar(test.key)) pubKey := privKey.PubKey() hash := hexToBytes(test.hash) wantSig := hexToBytes("00" + test.wantSigR + test.wantSigS) // Test compact signatures for both the compressed and uncompressed // versions of the public key. for _, compressed := range []bool{true, false} { // Populate the expected compact signature recovery code. wantRecoveryCode := compactSigMagicOffset + test.wantCode if compressed { wantRecoveryCode += compactSigCompPubKey } wantSig[0] = wantRecoveryCode // Sign the hash of the message with the given private key and // ensure the generated signature is the expected value per the // specified compressed flag. gotSig := SignCompact(privKey, hash, compressed) if !bytes.Equal(gotSig, wantSig) { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected signature -- got %x, want %x", test.name, gotSig, wantSig) continue } // Ensure the recovered public key and flag that indicates whether // or not the signature was for a compressed public key are the // expected values. gotPubKey, gotCompressed, err := RecoverCompact(gotSig, hash) if err != nil { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected error when recovering: %v", test.name, err) continue } if gotCompressed != compressed { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected compressed flag -- got %v, want %v", test.name, gotCompressed, compressed) continue } if !gotPubKey.IsEqual(pubKey) { t.Errorf("%s: unexpected public key -- got %x, want %x", test.name, gotPubKey.SerializeUncompressed(), pubKey.SerializeUncompressed()) continue } } } } // TestRecoverCompactErrors ensures several error paths in compact signature // recovery are detected as expected. When possible, the signatures are // otherwise valid with the exception of the specific failure to ensure it's // robust against things like fault attacks. func TestRecoverCompactErrors(t *testing.T) { t.Parallel() tests := []struct { name string // test description sig string // hex encoded signature to recover pubkey from hash string // hex encoded hash of message err error // expected error }{{ name: "empty signature", sig: "", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigInvalidLen, }, { // Signature created from private key 0x02, blake256(0x01020304). name: "no compact sig recovery code (otherwise valid sig)", sig: "e6f137b52377250760cc702e19b7aee3c63b0e7d95a91939b14ab3b5c4771e59" + "44b9bc4620afa158b7efdfea5234ff2d5f2f78b42886f02cf581827ee55318ea", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigInvalidLen, }, { // Signature created from private key 0x02, blake256(0x01020304). name: "signature one byte too long (S padded with leading zero)", sig: "1f" + "e6f137b52377250760cc702e19b7aee3c63b0e7d95a91939b14ab3b5c4771e59" + "0044b9bc4620afa158b7efdfea5234ff2d5f2f78b42886f02cf581827ee55318ea", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigInvalidLen, }, { // Signature created from private key 0x02, blake256(0x01020304). name: "compact sig recovery code too low (otherwise valid sig)", sig: "1a" + "e6f137b52377250760cc702e19b7aee3c63b0e7d95a91939b14ab3b5c4771e59" + "44b9bc4620afa158b7efdfea5234ff2d5f2f78b42886f02cf581827ee55318ea", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigInvalidRecoveryCode, }, { // Signature created from private key 0x02, blake256(0x01020304). name: "compact sig recovery code too high (otherwise valid sig)", sig: "23" + "e6f137b52377250760cc702e19b7aee3c63b0e7d95a91939b14ab3b5c4771e59" + "44b9bc4620afa158b7efdfea5234ff2d5f2f78b42886f02cf581827ee55318ea", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigInvalidRecoveryCode, }, { // Signature invented since finding a signature with an r value that is // exactly the group order prior to the modular reduction is not // calculable without breaking the underlying crypto. name: "R == group order", sig: "1f" + "fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffebaaedce6af48a03bbfd25e8cd0364141" + "44b9bc4620afa158b7efdfea5234ff2d5f2f78b42886f02cf581827ee55318ea", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigRTooBig, }, { // Signature invented since finding a signature with an r value that // would be valid modulo the group order and is still 32 bytes is not // calculable without breaking the underlying crypto. name: "R > group order and still 32 bytes (order + 1)", sig: "1f" + "fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffebaaedce6af48a03bbfd25e8cd0364142" + "44b9bc4620afa158b7efdfea5234ff2d5f2f78b42886f02cf581827ee55318ea", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigRTooBig, }, { // Signature invented since the only way a signature could have an r // value of zero is if the nonce were zero which is invalid. name: "R == 0", sig: "1f" + "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000" + "44b9bc4620afa158b7efdfea5234ff2d5f2f78b42886f02cf581827ee55318ea", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigRIsZero, }, { // Signature invented since finding a signature with an s value that is // exactly the group order prior to the modular reduction is not // calculable without breaking the underlying crypto. name: "S == group order", sig: "1f" + "e6f137b52377250760cc702e19b7aee3c63b0e7d95a91939b14ab3b5c4771e59" + "fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffebaaedce6af48a03bbfd25e8cd0364141", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigSTooBig, }, { // Signature invented since finding a signature with an s value that // would be valid modulo the group order and is still 32 bytes is not // calculable without breaking the underlying crypto. name: "S > group order and still 32 bytes (order + 1)", sig: "1f" + "e6f137b52377250760cc702e19b7aee3c63b0e7d95a91939b14ab3b5c4771e59" + "fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffebaaedce6af48a03bbfd25e8cd0364142", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigSTooBig, }, { // Signature created by forcing the key/hash/nonce choices such that s // is zero and is therefore invalid. The signing code will not produce // such a signature in practice. name: "S == 0", sig: "1f" + "e6f137b52377250760cc702e19b7aee3c63b0e7d95a91939b14ab3b5c4771e59" + "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000", hash: "393bec84f1a04037751c0d6c2817f37953eaa204ac0898de7adb038c33a20438", err: ErrSigSIsZero, }, { // Signature invented since finding a private key needed to create a // valid signature with an r value that is >= group order prior to the // modular reduction is not possible without breaking the underlying // crypto. name: "R >= field prime minus group order with overflow bit", sig: "21" + "000000000000000000000000000000014551231950b75fc4402da1722fc9baee" + "44b9bc4620afa158b7efdfea5234ff2d5f2f78b42886f02cf581827ee55318ea", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrSigOverflowsPrime, }, { // Signature invented since finding a private key needed to create a // valid signature with an r value that is > group order prior to the // modular reduction is not possible without breaking the underlying // crypto. name: "R > group order with overflow bit", sig: "21" + "000000000000000000000000000000014551231950b75fc4402da1722fc9baed" + "44b9bc4620afa158b7efdfea5234ff2d5f2f78b42886f02cf581827ee55318ea", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrPointNotOnCurve, }, { // Signature created from private key 0x01, blake256(0x0102030407) over // the secp256r1 curve (note the r1 instead of k1). name: "pubkey not on the curve, signature valid for secp256r1 instead", sig: "1f" + "2a81d1b3facc22185267d3f8832c5104902591bc471253f1cfc5eb25f4f740f2" + "72e65d019f9b09d769149e2be0b55de9b0224d34095bddc6a5dba90bfda33c45", hash: "9165e957708bc95cf62d020769c150b2d7b08e7ab7981860815b1eaabd41d695", err: ErrPointNotOnCurve, }, { // Signature created from private key 0x01, blake256(0x01020304) and // manually setting s = -e*k^-1. name: "calculated pubkey point at infinity", sig: "1f" + "c6c4137b0e5fbfc88ae3f293d7e80c8566c43ae20340075d44f75b009c943d09" + "1281d8d90a5774045abd57b453c7eadbc830dbadec89ae8dd7639b9cc55641d0", hash: "c301ba9de5d6053caad9f5eb46523f007702add2c62fa39de03146a36b8026b7", err: ErrPointNotOnCurve, }} for _, test := range tests { // Parse test data. hash := hexToBytes(test.hash) sig := hexToBytes(test.sig) // Ensure the expected error is hit. _, _, err := RecoverCompact(sig, hash) if !errors.Is(err, test.err) { t.Errorf("%s: mismatched err -- got %v, want %v", test.name, err, test.err) continue } } } // TestSignAndRecoverCompactRandom ensures compact (recoverable public key) // ECDSA signing and recovery work as expected for randomly-generated private // keys and messages. It also ensures mutated signatures and messages do not // improperly recover the original public key. func TestSignAndRecoverCompactRandom(t *testing.T) { t.Parallel() // Use a unique random seed each test instance and log it if the tests fail. seed := time.Now().Unix() rng := rand.New(rand.NewSource(seed)) defer func(t *testing.T, seed int64) { if t.Failed() { t.Logf("random seed: %d", seed) } }(t, seed) for i := 0; i < 100; i++ { // Generate a random private key. var buf [32]byte if _, err := rng.Read(buf[:]); err != nil { t.Fatalf("failed to read random private key: %v", err) } var privKeyScalar secp256k1.ModNScalar privKeyScalar.SetBytes(&buf) privKey := secp256k1.NewPrivateKey(&privKeyScalar) wantPubKey := privKey.PubKey() // Generate a random hash to sign. var hash [32]byte if _, err := rng.Read(hash[:]); err != nil { t.Fatalf("failed to read random hash: %v", err) } // Test compact signatures for both the compressed and uncompressed // versions of the public key. for _, compressed := range []bool{true, false} { // Sign the hash with the private key and then ensure the original // public key and compressed flag is recovered from the produced // signature. gotSig := SignCompact(privKey, hash[:], compressed) gotPubKey, gotCompressed, err := RecoverCompact(gotSig, hash[:]) if err != nil { t.Fatalf("unexpected err: %v\nsig: %x\nhash: %x\nprivate key: %x", err, gotSig, hash, privKey.Serialize()) } if gotCompressed != compressed { t.Fatalf("unexpected compressed flag: %v\nsig: %x\nhash: %x\n"+ "private key: %x", gotCompressed, gotSig, hash, privKey.Serialize()) } if !gotPubKey.IsEqual(wantPubKey) { t.Fatalf("unexpected recovered public key: %x\nsig: %x\nhash: "+ "%x\nprivate key: %x", gotPubKey.SerializeUncompressed(), gotSig, hash, privKey.Serialize()) } // Change a random bit in the signature and ensure the bad signature // fails to recover the original public key. badSig := make([]byte, len(gotSig)) copy(badSig, gotSig) randByte := rng.Intn(len(badSig)-1) + 1 randBit := rng.Intn(7) badSig[randByte] ^= 1 << randBit badPubKey, _, err := RecoverCompact(badSig, hash[:]) if err == nil && badPubKey.IsEqual(wantPubKey) { t.Fatalf("recovered public key for bad sig: %x\nhash: %x\n"+ "private key: %x", badSig, hash, privKey.Serialize()) } // Change a random bit in the hash that was originally signed and // ensure the original good signature fails to recover the original // public key. badHash := make([]byte, len(hash)) copy(badHash, hash[:]) randByte = rng.Intn(len(badHash)) randBit = rng.Intn(7) badHash[randByte] ^= 1 << randBit badPubKey, _, err = RecoverCompact(gotSig, badHash) if err == nil && badPubKey.IsEqual(wantPubKey) { t.Fatalf("recovered public key for bad hash: %x\nsig: %x\n"+ "private key: %x", badHash, gotSig, privKey.Serialize()) } } } }